Skip to content
KinPilot™Learn & Explore
Menu

Grades 9–12 · History & Evidence

Why can ice and trapped air at the same depth have different ages?

An ice core can preserve records in both its solid ice and its enclosed gases. Those records do not automatically refer to the same time, even at the same depth. The solid layer began as snowfall, whereas air could continue exchanging with the atmosphere before it became trapped.

H25 visual explanationFictional chronology relative to a shared reference year: ice layer age 1000 years and supplied ice-minus-mean-gas age offset 200 years give representative mean gas age 800 years. Air exchanges through porous firn before bubble closure, so gas is younger than surrounding ice. Real firn transport yields an age distribution, and offsets vary by site and conditions; none of these numbers models an actual core.Ice layers and enclosed air have different agesSupplied fictional ages · shared reference yearSnowPorous firnClosed iceAir exchanges before pores close.Ice age: 1000 yearsGiven offset: 200 yearsGas mean: 800 yearsAir trapped later is younger than its surrounding ice.

In the diagramIce layers and enclosed air have different agesSupplied fictional ages · shared reference yearSnowPorous firnClosed iceAir exchanges before pores close.Ice age: 1000 yearsGiven offset: 200 yearsGas mean: 800 yearsAir trapped later is younger than its surrounding ice.

The initial fictional layer age is 1000 years and its supplied ice-minus-mean-gas difference is 200 years, giving a representative mean gas age of 800 years.

Compacted snow passes through a porous stage called firn. Connected spaces between grains permit air movement and diffusion. As the firn becomes denser, those pathways gradually close and bubbles become isolated. The air then enclosed is generally younger than the surrounding ice, which has already spent time being buried and compacted.

Researchers therefore distinguish an ice chronology from a gas chronology. The ice-minus-gas age difference is often called Δage. It depends on conditions such as temperature, snowfall accumulation and firn transport, rather than being a single correction valid for every core or depth.

Our fictional layer is 1000 years old relative to a shared reference year. Its supplied difference is 200 years, so the representative mean gas age is 800 years. The subtraction compares ages before that same reference; it does not mean that air molecules themselves were created 800 years ago.

Real gas samples contain a distribution of atmospheric ages because exchange and closure are gradual. This can smooth a changing atmospheric signal. Comparing an ice-based climate record with a gas-based record therefore requires their separate dating evidence and uncertainties, not simply matching their positions in the core.

About this explanation

Starting knowledge: Understand age before a shared reference year, subtraction of age offsets and the distinction between solid layers and air in their pores.

Sources

  • Epifanio and colleagues, Climate of the Past — The SP19 chronology for the South Pole Ice Core – Part 2: gas chronology, Δage, and smoothing of atmospheric records
  • Michael Bender, Todd Sowers and Edward Brook, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences — Gases in ice cores
← Grades 9–12 topics